In addition to the fact Amazon reviewers and experts agree “in aggregate about the quality of a book,” non-professional reviews on Amazon tend to be “more eclectic,” “more supportive of debut authors,” and less biased in favor of authors with whom they associate than media experts.
Matthew Schantz is an intern for The Millions. He is currently studying English and Russian at Columbia University.
More From Curiosities
- George and Robin August 21, 2014
- Sister Golden Hair Excerpt August 21, 2014
- “Hauntedness is a feeling.” August 21, 2014
- “If I wasn’t such a deadbeat, I’d learn Greek.” August 21, 2014
- Agent of Chaos August 20, 2014
- View All
Other Recent Articles
- This Could Be Your Story: On Matthew Thomas’s We Are Not Ourselves August 21, 2014
- Practical Art: On Teaching the Business of Creative Writing August 20, 2014
- Back to School: Six Strategies for Effective Close Reading August 19, 2014
- Just What Is It That Makes Today’s Eco-terrorists So Different, So Appealing? August 18, 2014
- Mind of a Team: David Peace’s Red or Dead August 18, 2014
- View All
- elko says "Modern eco-terrorism has become a fixation among film makers because these fringe activists fall prey to..."Just What Is It That Makes Today’s Eco-terrorists So Different, So Appealing?
- Moe Murph says "Re Ross: Wonderful excerpt from the review you just mentioned: [Quite soon, “there was nothing left of either love or..."Practical Art: On Teaching the Business of Creative Writing
- Janelle says "I think Sherman Alexie’s “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian” was already mentioned, but it is such a..."Students’ Picks: The Best YA Books of 2013
- Marina Hopkins says "Let’s keep the faith — some creative writing majors are getting very successful, and rich...."Practical Art: On Teaching the Business of Creative Writing
- Ross says "Here’s the NY Times review of Chang’s novel, which I mentioned above. It covers some of what I was saying. As the..."Practical Art: On Teaching the Business of Creative Writing