Difficult Books and Notable Articles

Introducing Difficult Books, A Descriptive List

By posted at 6:59 am on October 29, 2009 69

Whether scholars, creative writers, or citizen book lovers, most readers agree on a canon of certain legendarily difficult books—books that are hard to read for their length, or their syntax and style, or their structural and generic strangeness, or their odd experimental techniques, or their abstraction.  This post inaugurates a new Millions series devoted to identifying and describing these most difficult books: ones we’ve read/wrangled with ourselves, ones we’ve known students to struggle with time and again, ones that, more simply, “everyone knows” are hard to read—those works whose mere titles glisten with an aura of rarefied impenetrability.

covercovercovercoverThere will, doubtless, be those readers who look scornfully on our choices (“Psh. These aren’t that hard, you’re just not smart enough to read them“). Indeed, for myself, that is probably true. And to those so brilliant that not a one of these tomes challenged or vexed them more than a People magazine, we tip our hats.  This list is for the mere mortals among us—who have found themselves reading and rereading the same paragraph of James Joyce’s Ulysses to no avail, who have been reduced to tears by Faulkner’s one-line chapter, “My mother is a fish,” in As I Lay Dying, who may have spitefully broken the brittle spine of her first used copy of Tristram Shandy, who use a volume of Gibbon’s History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire as a doorstop and eye it with a wary distrust when she walks past it (for it is fond of stubbing toes).

But this is also a list for those who, after breaking the spine, picked up the wounded volume, taped it back together, and finished that infuriating chapter, and another, and another… until, triumph!, it was finished at last. And, perhaps, now that we think on it again, having finished, could it be that it was worth the struggle? Could it be that in the pain of it was a tinge of pleasure, of value (not to mention pride)?

The hope is that our series will eventually be exhaustive, and because this is a series and so on-going, we welcome your suggestions. Where we can, we also offer our advice to aspiring readers of a particular difficult work. Our descriptions aim to be modest primers for those about to embark on the reading of a difficult book, as well as small, memorial essays on these (by many measures) great books. Titles will come from many eras and genres—the Renaissance, the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the high Modernism of the early twentieth century, and finally our own time, and we include fiction, poetry, philosophy, and critical theory. Titles will be primarily those written in English, but in some cases we include translations. Future posts will cover works by Immanuel Kant, G.W. F. Hegel, Marcel Proust, Robert Musil, James Joyce, Ezra Pound, Virginia Woolf, Gertrude Stein,  Djuna Barnes, William Vollmann, Thomas Pynchon, Jacques Derrida, David Foster Wallace, Joseph McElroy, Donna Harraway, William H. Gass, William Gaddis, and others.

1621: The Anatomy of Melancholy by Robert Burton
1667: Paradise Lost by John Milton
1704: A Tale of a Tub by Jonathan Swift
1747-8: Clarissa by Samuel Richardson
1759-67: The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy, Gentleman by Laurence Sterne
1851: Moby Dick by Herman Melville
1922-62: The Cantos by Ezra Pound
1927: To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf
1964: The Sonnets by Ted Berrigan
1969: The Dream Songs by John Berryman
1969: Ada, or Ardor by Vladimir Nabokov
1974: Dhalgren by Samuel R. Delany





Share this article

More from the Millions

69 Responses to “Introducing Difficult Books, A Descriptive List”

  1. jordy
    at 1:25 am on August 8, 2012

    i am surprise that the bible is not number one , very difficult to read and everybody have a different interpretation

    it have all murder ,mystery, science fiction , mass murder ,jealousy ,erotic poems ,magic.

    plus not many have read it covert to covert , one problem though no jokes !

  2. Mats
    at 10:57 am on August 8, 2012

    I’ve read (and felt I understood) quite a few difficult philosophers like Derrida, Heidegger, Hegel, Adorno, Baudrillard and even Lacan, but nothing could get me through Being and Nothingness, by Sartre.

  3. Ten Most Difficult Books « Gyrovague's Raves
    at 1:12 am on August 9, 2012

    […] in 2009, The Millions started its "Difficult Books" series–devoted to identifying the hardest and most frustrating books ever written, as well as what […]

  4. ‘Moeilijke’ boeken – Hoeveel heb jij er gelezen? | Scriptgirl.nl
    at 3:24 am on August 9, 2012

    […] twee auteurs van de literaire website The Millions zichzelf. En verrek, ze kwamen op de proppen met een lijstje van boeken waar je met de beste wil van de wereld amper doorheen komt. The Guardian pakte het nieuws op en […]

  5. White Whales – The Books That Drive Us | www.booksandlibations.com
    at 4:15 am on August 9, 2012

    […] are my personal challenges. If these don’t float your boat Publisher’s Weekly and The Millions both provide some really brutal […]

  6. Anders
    at 2:39 pm on August 9, 2012

    Great project, sweet feeling of investment paying off when you have suffered through some entry on the list.

    If the flood gates are opened to french philosophy, well, there are many… but Lacan and his Écrits should definitly be considered. Derrida just need a friendly explanation, but Lacan never intended something as mundane as being understood. Even Zizek admits it: unreadable.

  7. Flavorwire » Are These the 10 Most Difficult Books?
    at 3:05 pm on August 9, 2012

    […] Emily Colette Wilkinson and Garth Risk Hallberg, co-curators of The Millions’ long-running “Difficult Books” series, recently compiled an interesting list of what they deem to be “the most difficult of the […]

  8. Sapete quali sono i 10 libri più difficili da leggere? | agora-vox.co.cc
    at 10:59 am on August 10, 2012

    […] mai chiesti qual è il libro più difficile da leggere in assoluto? Una giornalista americana del The Million, Emily Colette Wilkinson nel 2009 pubblicò una lista dei 10 libri più ostici da leggere. […]

  9. Haftadan Kalanlar // 6-12 Ağustos 2012 | koltukname
    at 4:42 am on August 11, 2012

    […] mi olur, ben böyle listelere itibar etmem diyenlerdenseniz, size alternatif liste: The Millions, Zor Kitaplar Listesi yapıyor. Publisher’s Weekly‘ye de zorun zoru 10 kitaplık ayrı bir liste yapmışlar. […]

  10. Nemo
    at 5:57 pm on August 11, 2012

    I second two books: Darconville’s Cat-moreover, you
    reach the point of increasing returns.

    And Oswald Spengler’s Decline-the 2 volume unabridged set with fold-out
    charts will make for instant discombobulation.

    Also Laura Warholic by Theroux.

  11. AnnAlysis Sunday Times: Lee Child Reads, Some Great New Releases and a Quote From a Book I Can’t Put Down
    at 6:27 am on August 12, 2012

    […] The Millions breaks down some of the most difficult books in the literary world […]

  12. Davey
    at 12:17 am on August 15, 2012

    I loved “Moby Dick” when I read it in the 1980s, but that was because I had the now out-of-print Harold Beaver edition from Penguin with its 300 pages of notes telling you what you need to know.
    I have loved the first 3 pages of “Ulysses” each and every time I have read them.
    Wittgenstein’s “Tractatus”, ugh.
    Carlyle’s “Sartor Resartus” is actually supposed to be funny, rather than impenetrable. Melville was inspired by Carlyle but lightened up the prose.
    Wright’s “Arabic Grammar” (Dover reprint) is easily the best Arabic grammar I know, but the author assumes the reader already reads Arabic, as well as German, French, Latin, Greek, Hebrew, Aramaic, Syriac, Coptic and Ethiopic, so people who had trouble with Spanish …

  13. jj
    at 3:58 pm on August 24, 2012

    My nominee is Finnegans Wake by James Joyce. Clarissa is a walk in the park compared to this.

  14. Just can’t finish… – Lead.Learn.Live.
    at 8:17 pm on August 30, 2012

    […] “Difficult Books” series is devoted to identifying the hardest and most frustrating books ever written, as well as what made […]

  15. Lauren Wills
    at 2:53 pm on March 11, 2014

    And of course the unpublished Chiliad by Simon Otius at unhappened [dot] com.

  16. Enon Sci
    at 4:12 pm on July 13, 2014

    I’d nominate Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell, and The Illuminatus Trilogy, by Robert Anton Wilson and Shea. The former due to its postmodern and semi-experimental semiotics; the latter due to its length. The people I’ve met who have abandoned these works far outweigh those who have completed them.

    Cloud Atlas, however, is a higher achievement. Amazing work.

  17. Literary Links | Emily Eckart
    at 10:18 pm on October 13, 2014

    […] The Millions’s list of difficult books […]

  18. david
    at 2:15 pm on November 15, 2014

    i guess the books were too difficult to complete the list.

  19. Tackling Tough Books | Time's Flow Stemmed
    at 8:45 am on January 3, 2015

    […] within a decade. You have probably come across the fantastic series of articles running at The Millions, encouraging readers to tackle a series of “difficult” […]

Post a Response

Comments with unrelated links will be deleted. If you'd like to reach our readers, consider buying an advertisement instead.

Anonymous and pseudonymous comments that do not add to the conversation will be deleted at our discretion.